Trump’s Tariff Policies A Look Back and Forward

Trump's Tariff Policies A Look Back and Forward

Trump’s Tariff Policies in March 2018, just a day after announcing broad tariffs on metals imported from America’s allies and adversaries alike, President Donald J. Trump took to social media to share one of his core economic beliefs: Trade wars are good, and easy to win.

During his presidency, Mr. Trump oversaw the largest increase in U.S. tariffs since the Great Depression. He targeted China, Canada, the European Union, Mexico, India, and other nations with hefty duties. These countries retaliated by imposing tariffs on American soybeans, whiskey, orange juice, and motorcycles. As a result, U.S. agricultural exports plummeted, prompting Mr. Trump to allocate $23 billion to farmers to offset their losses.

Campaigning for Another Term

Now, as he campaigns for another term, Mr. Trump vows to escalate his trade war significantly. He has proposed universal baseline tariffs on most foreign products, including higher duties on countries that devalue their currency. In interviews, he has mentioned plans for a 10 percent tariff on most imports and a 60 percent tariff or higher on Chinese goods. He has also suggested cutting federal income tax and relying on tariffs for revenue instead.

Trump’s trade strategy aims to boost tariffs sharply, focusing on protectionism over income tax cuts, acording to WSJ Digital Subscription.

The Tariff Man’s Beliefs

Mr. Trump, known as Tariff Man, claimed tariffs would bolster American factories, shrink the trade gap, and spur job creation. His tariffs initially targeted $400 billion in imports, impacting steel, solar panels, washing machines, and Chinese products such as smartwatches and chemicals. He aimed to rejuvenate U.S. manufacturing, reduce dependence on foreign goods, and help domestic companies compete with inexpensive imports from China and elsewhere.

Economic Impact

Economists acknowledge that the tariffs reduced imports and encouraged U.S. factory production in certain industries, such as steel, semiconductors, and computer equipment. However, this came at a significant cost, likely negating any overall benefits. Studies indicate that the tariffs led to higher prices for American consumers and industries reliant on foreign inputs, while also reducing U.S. exports of goods that faced retaliatory tariffs.


Potential Political Upheavals in Europe

Potential political upheavals have emerged recently across Europe, diverting attention from the region’s improving economic fundamentals…

Consequences of New Tariffs

Mr. Trump is now considering taxing perhaps ten times as many imports as during his first term, a strategy economists warn could spark a trade war, increase already high prices, and push the U.S. into a recession.

David Autor, an economics professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, said the proposals would have a very large effect on prices almost immediately.

I don’t think they’ll do it, Mr. Autor added. It could easily cause a recession.

In a recent letter, 16 Nobel Prize-winning economists expressed their deep concern about the risks a second Trump administration posed to the economy, inflation, and the rule of law.

We believe that a second Trump term would have a negative impact on the U.S.’s economic standing in the world and a destabilizing effect on the U.S.’s domestic economy, they wrote.

Supporters’ Views

Mr. Trump and his supporters view tariffs more positively, arguing that they serve as leverage with foreign governments, reduce the trade deficit with China, and foster the growth of U.S. manufacturing jobs.

I happen to be a big believer in tariffs because I think tariffs give you two things: They give you economic gain, but they also give you political gain, Mr. Trump said on a recent podcast.

Karoline Leavitt, the Trump campaign national press secretary, stated, the American people don’t need worthless out-of-touch Nobel Prize winners to tell them which president put more money in their pockets.

President Trump built the strongest economy in American history, she said. In just three years, Joe Biden’s out-of-control spending created the worst inflation crisis in generations.

Industry Reactions

Jamieson L. Greer, a partner in the international trade team at King & Spalding who was involved with China trade negotiations during the Trump administration, said Trump officials believed tariffs can help support U.S. manufacturing jobs, especially by addressing unfair trade practices.

China has long engaged in policies that disadvantage American workers, but other countries also have unfair trade and tax policies or misaligned currencies, Mr. Greer noted.

If you level out that playing field, it makes it so that Americans don’t have to compete unfairly, he said.

Domestic and International Effects

Mr. Trump’s tariffs policies have domestic supporters among the industries that benefited from them. President Biden also kept Mr. Trump’s China tariffs in place and added his own, including on electric cars, steel, and semiconductors. However, some industries hit hardest by Mr. Trump’s trade wars are not keen on a repeat. Executives in sectors like retail and spirits worry that another round of tariffs could reignite tensions, increase their costs, and close off crucial markets abroad.

Spirit exports to Europe dropped by 20 percent following the EU’s 25 percent tariff on American whiskey. Retailers faced higher prices due to China tariffs, prompting them to either raise prices or cut profits.

David French, EVP of government relations at the National Retail Federation, stresses the necessity of a holistic trade policy. His group, representing department stores, e-commerce sites, and grocers, aired a TV campaign opposing Trump’s tariffs in 2018. These tariffs have hiked supply chain challenges, adding a $220 billion expense for consumers.

The Power of Tariffs

The power of tariffs to help or hinder exports is evident in industries that eventually won a reprieve. In 2021, whiskey tariffs were temporarily suspended as part of a deal the Biden administration made with the European Union. American whiskey exports to the bloc rose from $439 million in 2021 to $705 million last year.

Chris Swonger, CEO of the Distilled Spirits Council, anticipates Trump’s re-election to boost U.S. spirits exports, aiding trade deficit reduction. The group urges extending the E.U. tariff suspension beyond March to preserve trade advantages.

Mr. Swonger, who has advocated to Trump campaign officials, appreciates President Trump’s efforts to cut the trade deficit. However, he believes tariffs on distilled spirits would hinder achieving that goal.

Research Findings

Research indicates that tariffs boosted domestic production in protected industries but imposed costs on the U.S. economy. A nonpartisan government study highlighted that steel and aluminum tariffs increased U.S. metal production by $2.2 billion in 2021. However, manufacturers using these materials faced higher costs, reducing their output by $3.5 billion annually. Industries like automotive, canning, and appliance manufacturing were particularly affected.

Impact on Jobs and Inflation

Studies indicate that tariffs had diverse effects on employment, with research suggesting varied impacts. Mr. Autor and economists found Trump’s trade policies and retaliations offset American job gains. Inflation studies suggest tariffs raised household expenses by hundreds to over $1,000 annually.

However, economists suggest consumers probably didn’t associate the higher prices they paid with the tariffs. Inflation was low during Mr. Trump’s tenure, and the economy was strong. Since 2021, prices have surged, and inflation remains elevated, potentially making tariff-induced increases more noticeable and painful.

Future Projections

The Peterson Institute of International Economics projects tariffs may raise middle-income household expenses by $1,700 annually. The American Action Forum predicts higher costs, estimating up to $2,350 annually, largely due to tariffs on Chinese goods.

The burden of these tariffs disproportionately affects poorer households, who allocate more income to everyday goods. This strategy might backfire on Mr. Trump, especially with inflation becoming a major concern for voters.

Voter Concerns

Paul Rozick, an electrical warehouse manager from Bensalem, Pa., mentioned waiting in line for Mr. Trump’s rally in Philadelphia, citing that high grocery and gas prices had surpassed his pay increases.

Inflation is going up like 20 percent, but our paychecks go up like 2 percent, Mr. Rozick said. I’ve got less money in the bank because I’m spending more money when I walk out the door.

Get a 2-year subscription to WSJ and Barron’s News, available on iOS/Android/PC/Mac. Enjoy unlimited access to WSJ, Barron’s, Peggy Noonan’s articles, Barron’s stock picks, WSJ live TV, WSJ audible articles, and Barron’s magazine.

Call Now Button